Agencies issue grim poverty warning UN, World Bank say decade’s gains at risk for emerging Europe, CIS

14/05/2009 | Simon Pirani

The economic recession in Europe and central Asia threatens to wipe out much of a decade’s worth of poverty reduction, international institutions have warned.

The crisis will push “back into poverty and vulnerability” almost 35 million people – about one third of the number that have escaped from it over the last ten years, a World Bank report warned last month.

Ben Slay, senior economist (Europe and CIS) at the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), told Emerging Markets: “What is specific about the Europe and central Asia region is that many, many people have been lifted out of poverty in the last decade by economic growth – rather than, say, changes in economic structure or by welfare programmes – and, without that growth, they will fall back.

“In this respect the region is more vulnerable in this economic crisis than regions such as Asia and Africa that are poorer overall.”

The World Bank expects that the number of poor and vulnerable people in the region will rise by 5 million for every 1% decline in GDP – which suggests, according to Bank economists, that by the end of 2009 almost 25 million more people will be poor and vulnerable, and by the end of 2010 a further 10 million.

Of the region’s 480 million people, 192 million are considered poor or vulnerable by the Bank, and nearly 90 million have moved out of poverty and vulnerability since 1999. The reversal of the trend is a “human crisis that is going largely unnoticed”, Shigeo Katsu, the World Bank’s president for Europe and Central Asia, said in Washington late last month.

Slay at the UNDP said the Bank’s figures were based on the most thorough research available, but added that, “if anything, the numbers are optimistic”.

He said that former communist countries are often distinguished by spending “a fair proportion of GDP – higher than most African and Asian countries” on social protection – but that the systems are “very inefficient and often don’t necessarily provide support to the right people”. These need to be reorganised.

Slay said that in Bosnia, for example, while aid is targeted to war veterans, child poverty is not dealt with. The crisis begs the question: “Is it time to renegotiate the social contract?”

Another challenge, Slay argued, is to envisage a new growth model for the region as it begins to recover.

“It is an open question as to whether foreign investors will come in again, and foreign lenders will lend again, as they did in the 2000s. Countries in the region will need to consider how to move away from current account deficits of 15% of GDP.”

Erik Berglof, chief economist at the EBRD, said that the Bank’s work went alongside poverty reduction work insofar as “private sector development and [...] bringing [the poor] into productive work to mitigate the impact of the downturn”.

Related Articles

IMF 2015: Interview with the Chilean Minister of Finance

Editor's Picks

In Focus

  1. Climate finance: issues still remain between rich, poor states

  2. Italy must tackle NPLs fast to release business lending, Visco warns

  3. World Bank’s Kim warns of stretched finances and reform timebomb

  4. Brazil: in a hole and still digging

  5. End zero risk weights for government bonds, says Bundesbank’s Dombret