Questions grow over dollar’s future

06/10/2009 | Phil Thornton

Leading economists point to end for greenback as world reserve currency

The dollar’s era as the global reserve currency may be coming to an end, according to two economists – one a senior academic and the other a longstanding anti-poverty campaigner.

In article in the IMF's magazine Finance & Development published this month, Cohen said the dollar’s prospects had got dimmer but stressed that those of its main rivals – the euro, yen and Chinese yuan – appeared little better.

"A more fragmented currency system seems in the offing, with much competition and no money clearly dominant,” he said, adding that the economic and political impacts could be “considerable”.

He warned that without some form of leadership, global monetary relations would at risk of instability or worse. But he said that a more fragmented system would not necessarily be a “bad thing”.

“As the supplier of the world’s most popular currency, the US is in the position of a monopolist that has grown complacent abusing its exorbitant privilege,” he said.

Ann Pettifor, who parodied the IMF’s 2003 annual economic forecast with her own “real” World Economic Outlook that predicted a rich world debt crisis, said only radical reform of the financial architecture would prevent another financial crisis. But she dismissed the idea of using the IMF’s currency, the Special Depositary Receipt (SDR), saying that the Fund has been “captured” by the Group of Eight rich nations.

“We have to end the role of the US dollar as the global reserve currency,” she told Emerging Markets. “It is a large injustice that poor countries are obliged to hold Treasury bills.

"We need a new framework but I am not sure if SDRs can play that role. We need a new debate. It can’t happen overnight but Istanbul is a good place to start thinking about it.”

“I’m not sure that’s a role for the IMF but perhaps for the Bank for International Settlements,” she said. “Keynes’s big idea was for an independent global central bank to facilitate trade and act as a global clearing bank.”

She said the new central bank could accumulate reserves from surplus countries and use those to correct imbalances with deficit countries. “It needs a bank that is seen to be independent. The IMF is seen to be captured by the G8,” she said.

Her comments echo recommendations by a United Nations commissions into monetary reform chaired by Nobel laureate Joseph Stiglitz for an “orderly transition” from the dollar-based system.

“It is peculiar that we would still have this dollar system when we are so globalised,” Stiglitz told Emerging Markets. “This highlights the need for a new global reserve system to replace the dollar-based system.”

Related stories

  • SIR SUMA CHAKRABARTI: The EBRD — a bank that evolves ...

    The European Bank for Reconstruction and Development is staging its annual meeting in Warsaw in a year that marks a number of important anniversaries for Poland, Eastern Europe and for the EBRD itself

  • EXCLUSIVE: China rides to Russia's rescue with investment ...

    The decision by a joint venture between Russia and China to invest up to $2bn in key infrastructure projects will relieve the pressure on the Russian government to attract funds to offset the massive flight of capital

  • Russian loan market freezes up despite $500m Uralkali deal

    An imminent signing of a $500m loan by Uralkali, the world’s largest potash producer, has not convinced bankers that Russia’s frozen international loan markets is anywhere near thawing out

  • HIGH YIELD: Bright CEE future for high yield bonds

    With investor bases converging, the hunt for yield unabating and alternatives needed to bank debt, it is surely only a matter of time before the central and eastern European high yield bond market regains momentum after being bogged down by the crisis in Ukraine

  • FINANCIAL MARKETS: CEE financial hubs steel themselves ...

    Warsaw is home to the largest CEE-headquartered stock exchange, Bucharest is rapidly trying to replicate the structure, while Vienna dominates the Central and Eastern Europe Stock Exchange Group. Throw the Moscow Exchange into the mix and the battle for the CEE power exchange will prove a fascinating one

Editor's Picks

In Focus

  1. RUSSIA: Putin’s Crimea victory risks economic defeat

  2. BANKING SECTOR: Cautious optimism returns to CEE banks as recovery begins

Over the past year, Russia made no big progress in terms of improving its economy.

Vladimir Tikhomirov, chief economist, Otkritie Securities