Petrobras investment plan under fire

21/03/2010 | Thierry Ogier

Oil industry sources warn that legislation for exploring new off-shore reserves in Brazil could be counter-productive

Petrobras, Brazil’s state-controlled oil company, is pressing ahead with its expanded investment programme – despite fresh delays in Congress approving a new regulatory framework for exploring new reserves.

But oil industry sources warn that the limits on private capital implied by the proposed legislation could be counter-productive.

The strategic debate on developing Brazil’s oil potential is getting increasingly contaminated by the murky electoral climate ahead of the October polls.

Petrobras envisages $47.3 billion of capital expenditure this year, as part of an ambitious five-year investment plan of up to $220 billion, compared to $175 billion earmarked in the previous 2009-2013 plan.

Almir Barbassa, Petrobras chief financial officer, said on Friday, presenting 2009 results, that the basis for expanding investment “is rising Brent [crude prices], and also assuming the capitalization gets underway, which we expect will happen by the end of July”.

The company is seeking increased capitalization, the amount of which has yet to be set, to help fund exploration in ultra deep waters below the salt layer. It is part of package of four bills that the Brazilian government sent to Congress last year.

The new investment plan, which sets a minimum of $200 billion until 2014, was unveiled as the company reported a 12% drop in net income in 2009 compared to 2008, at 29 billion reais. Its prospects have been boosted by discoveries of huge quantities of oil in ultra deep waters off the Brazilian coast that may triple reserves.

The laws proposed by the government would give Petrobras the lion’s share of the recently found oil wealth. It would in effect be the sole operator in the new oil fields with a minimum share of 30% in all of them.

Putting Petrobras in the driving seat as the single operator has worried private foreign investors. Enrique Cira, director for Latin America at IHS Cambridge Energy Research Associates, said: “This might be a turn off and a no-go for these very large integrated companies. The whole industry will suffer delays.”

The lower house has approved the package after much controversy on the role of Petrobras and changes in the distribution of royalties among Brazilian states and other local authorities. But the row is set to intensify as the senate comes to grasp with the issues, and disgruntled producer states threaten to go to the Supreme court due to revenue losses.

The governor of Rio de Janeiro, Sergio Cabral, went as far as saying the proposed changes would prevent his state to prepare to host the 2016 Olympics.

Adriano Pires, director of the Brazilian centre for infrastructure, commented: “This is a more interventionist policy with a greater presence of the state.”

The stakes have been raised very high ahead of the October general elections. “Introducing this in an election year also creates some sort of insecurity among investors and all of this is really bad,” Pires said.

“If [the legislation] is voted the way it is, it is not going to attract large private foreign companies in Brazil. Traditional companies such as Exxon Mobil and Shell will show less interest than they have until today.”

Related stories

  • Magical economic realism alive and well in Venezuela

    Venezuela’s annual inflation hit 57.3% in February, but a group of chamber of commerce leaders defied experts’ analysis to present a bullish case for investment in the country

  • COLOMBIA: Freeing up Colombia's economy

    In the enviable position of boasting low inflation as EM currencies tumble, Colombia appears well placed to withstand the shocks of changing global monetary policy. But for the economy to make sustainable strides, long-term improvements are needed – starting with infrastructure

  • Latin hopes grow for new China fiscal stimulus

    China’s plans to roll out a double-barrel fiscal and monetary stimulus package in the months ahead, in an attempt to stave off a marked slowdown in the world’s second largest economy, could offer a sliver of hope for Latin America’s struggling commodities exporters

  • BRAZIL: Rousseff running out of time to restore economic ...

    As Dilma Rousseff seeks re-election this October, her economic performance has proved disappointing. But policymakers have launched a counter-offensive to regain credibility

  • Busan 2015: Korea trade key to venue choice

    The decision by the IDB to site its 2015 annual meetings in South Korea highlights the region’s desire to build on a fast growing trade and business relationship

Editor's Picks

In Focus

  1. BRAZIL: Rousseff running out of time to restore economic credibility

  2. FINANCING LATAM’S BANKS: Niche currencies lead the way for LatAm exposure

  3. US QE tapering a good sign but watch the short end…

  4. JIM O'NEILL: Latin America can learn from Mexico’s efforts

  5. LATIN AMERICA: Filling the infrastructure financing gap