Finance chiefs warn on capital flows reversal

22/03/2010 | Greg Brosnan

Surge in developed world debt issuance and interest rates threaten emerging markets, policymakers caution

The risk is growing of a sudden reversal in capital flows to emerging markets that would severely punish economies without sound fiscal policies, policymakers warned yesterday.

Mexico’s central bank governor Agustin Carstens said a surge in developed world debt issuance and rising interest rates could torpedo recent investor enthusiasm for emerging markets.

“The bottom line for emerging markets – and that is something that worries me the most – is that the possibility of having sudden stops [in capital flows] is increasing pretty much for everybody,” Carstens said in Cancun.

He added that although Latin economies are “able to place long term debt and the market is receptive”, the likelihood of increased debt issues among large deficit industrialised countries could undermine emerging markets access to funds.

“Appetite for more risk in terms of EM might reduce. We might not have access to such long term financing,” Carstens added. “The tolerance of markets for fiscal [laxity] is not there.”

Ultra-easy US monetary policy and the cheap cost of dollar funding has led to a surge in emerging market asset prices, fuelled by the so-called dollar carry trade – where investors borrow in dollars and invest the money in high-yielding assets of another country.

Institute of International Finance (IIF) managing director Charles Dallara urged caution over the direction of US monetary policy. “The Fed will probably need to tighten monetary policy sooner than markets expect today. When the [US dollar] carry trade reverses, governments and central banks will have to be very careful.”

Former Mexican central banker Guillermo Ortiz echoed these concerns, urging policymakers to look to lessons from previous crises.

“There are worries about the carry trade,” Ortiz told Emerging Markets. “In the past when the US has reined in loose monetary policy, this entry of [capital] flows reverses, and sometime dramatically, and things start to go the other way. Volatility and risk aversion increase and countries with a weak external positions can end up in trouble.”

Lack of market confidence in the sustainability of public finances has historically conspired to create havoc in Latin America.

Ortiz added that Latin governments must “take advantage of these better times” to “continue the process of fiscal consolidation, to keep bringing down debt to GDP levels, continuing being more efficient in our economies, pushing through badly needed structural reforms.”

Philip Suttle, chief economist at the IIF, said: “We are now in the fourth bull run for emerging markets – and it’s important to note that the last three cycles ended in an a crisis.” He pointed to the “real threat of crowding out of emerging market borrowers in international markets by high G7 government spending”.

Former Brazilian finance minister Antonio Palocci called on the US spell out its exit strategy to avoid any adverse shocks to the global economy.

“There will be an impact all over the world but it is important that Latin American countries are duly informed,” he told Emerging Markets. “So far we have not seen any exit strategy from the US, I have got the impression that it does not exist.”

Related stories

  • Macedonia defiant on FDI threat in wake of fatal violence

    More than 20 people have died in riots in Macedonia but the country’s inward investment chief has told Emerging Markets that the nation is on track for eventual EU membership

  • UniCredit rebuffs Russian attack on 'profitable' Western banks

    The head of UniCredit’s CEE division tells Emerging Markets he intends to remain in Russia, despite claims by the head of the country’s sovereign wealth fund that he wants to cut Western banks’ market share by attracting Chinese lenders

  • Lack of capital, human talent to stall SME 'engines of growth'

    Leaders of SMEs that the EBRD sees as the “engines of growth” have voiced fears that obstacles such as lack of capital and opaque policies will stymie the bank’s vision for a highly profitable sector

  • Crisis ahead for Croatia without dramatic changes, warn ...

    A terrible cocktail of a vast debt pile, large fiscal deficit and lack of growth has pushed Croatia’s debt profile precariously close to unsustainable levels. Without comprehensive structural reforms, many believe the country’s economy will be in crisis by the end of the decade.

  • Ukraine taps private sector and Georgia to reform conflict ...

    President Petro Poroshenko and premier Arseniy Yatsenyuk have dipped into Georgia’s deep pool of reformist talent in an effort to rebuild Ukraine’s war-ravaged economy. However, even with a vast IMF package and other financial assistance, many have trouble seeing how Ukraine is ever going to return to growth while it is in conflict with the Russia-backed rebels in the east


Editor's Picks


In Focus

  1. Georgian jewel shines bright against Russian darkness

  2. Ukraine taps private sector and Georgia to reform conflict-ravaged economy