World Bank scores top marks

08/10/2010 | Andrea Armeni and Phil Thornton

The World Bank helped stabilize global growth thanks to record loans to emerging economies during the crisis, the bank’s internal auditor has found

The World Bank’s Independent Evaluation Group (IEG) has issued high marks for the Bank’s early response to the global financial crisis, rebutting claims that the Bank took a back seat.

Vinod Thomas, IEG Director-General, noted the significant positive impact of Bank financing, particularly for middle income countries.

While OECD countries have posted post-crisis growth of approximately 4%, middle income countries are closer to 8%, and developing countries as a whole approach 6%, Thomas pointed out.

He attributed the middle income countries’ strong performance to their having been great beneficiaries of IFI assistance – and while all IFIs sharply increased their financing in response to the crisis, the World Bank disbursed a record $80 billion between fiscal years 2009 and 2010. This was more than any other IFI in that time period.

“The increased lending by a dramatic amount by the World Bank in this context of recession reflects a role it has now played in helping to stabilize world economic growth,” Thomas told Emerging Markets.

One leading independent development think tank agreed that the World Bank had performed well during the crisis, but said there was room for improvement in its work with low income countries. Ben Leo, Research Fellow at the Center for Economic Development in Washington, said there was a “broad consensus” that the Bank had responded well to the crisis.

“I agree that the Bank responded very vigorously in the middle-income countries,” Leo told Emerging Markets. “Its institutional and capital structure allowed it to be much more agile.”

The record disbursement by the World Bank was due in part to the happenstance of low pre-crisis demand for funding from its middle-income country financing arm, the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD). This left the institution with significant leeway to increase its middle-income lending by nearly three times, according to official figures.

The International Development Association (IDA), the Bank’s funding arm for low-income countries, also made a positive response. Leo noted that the Bank moved swiftly to get resources to low income countries at the outset of the crisis – but the fact that IDA’s resources were limited to a fixed pot of money that it receives every three years meant it was constrained in what it could do.

The IEG’s analysis also addressed concerns that low income countries may have lost out to increased lending to middle income countries. “In a way there is no clear substitution,” Thomas noted. “The former does not take away from the latter. Without the former, the latter would get worse.”

While acknowledging the increases over the past two years, Thomas noted that “there is no doubt that additional funding [to low income countries] will be critical”.

The positive effect of the crisis-responsive funding bodes well for the World Bank’s future role, Thomas said.

“This kind of support from the multilaterals, the World Bank plus the others, is a major force in supporting and shoring up the stabilization of growth. This is a different role, a new role. It’s something to be reckoned with,” he said.

Related stories

  • World Bank pledges to work with countries in 'complicated' ...

    Now that the a decade-long economic boom has come to an end, Latin American countries are looking to engage with the World Bank to deal with development challenges amid more complex external conditions

  • Mexican central bank warns on weaker peso but welcomes ...

    Mexico’s deputy central bank governor tells Emerging Markets that overall his country will benefit rather than suffer from rising US interest rates but warns that a depreciation of the peso is a ‘risk’ to the otherwise positive outlook.

  • Robust growth remains elusive for Peru

    Ambition and reforms, Peru has aplenty. But despite getting many things right, it is not being rewarded with strong growth. In the year before the next presidential election frenzy, can Peru get moving again?

  • LatAm must look to private finance to fill yawning infrastructure ...

    Huge. Massive. Vast. Pick any of these words and it would more than adequately describe the need for infrastructure in Latin America and the Caribbean. But having failed to take advantage of the boom years to finance major projects, governments now need to look to the private sector to fill the gap.

  • China to turn off tap of easy credit to 'errant' LatAm states

    Chinese officials in Beijing are growing increasingly unhappy with the government’s policy of offering cheap loans without conditions to troubled Latin American states that might never be able to repay them.

Editor's Picks

In Focus

  1. No pain, no gain: Argentina gears up for necessary adjustment

  2. Deepening Petrobras scandal dogs Brazilian hopes of recovery